Log in

No account? Create an account
19 January 2004 @ 11:52 pm
Demotion? No way!  
I keep seeing references to Hughes' statement in ep 14 that Roy was 'demoted'.

But, I ask you, was he actually demoted?

Please remember: in episode 9, Roy is informed that he is going to become a Colonel, and be moved to East City. Now, the actual rank is moving up (Lt. Colonel to Colonel), but being removed from Central City is a 'demotion' in Roy's words - a suggestion that they are moving him away from the center of power, the place where all the action is.

The man informing Roy of his promotion/demotion argues that no, this is a promotion. He sees it as both a promotion of actual rank as well as governmental role, because Roy will now be expected to bring the troublesome East to the hand of the military. And with Edward Elric under his command, Roy ruthlessly does so. :)

Now, that happened 3 years ago in the current anime arc - the same time frame Hughes gives for the 'demotion'. Personally, I think that Hughes always agreed with Roy viewing the promotion/demotion as a demotion, and is merely referring back to when Roy was shipped off to East City.

So, real demotion of rank? I don't think so. Demotion in terms of power? Possibly. ^__^;;

Current Mood: intelligent
Current Music: 'Kesenai tsumi', FMA END
thegreatpeanuterpeanutbaby13 on January 19th, 2004 11:37 pm (UTC)
It was a 'demotion' of location
not of rank
Branchbranchandroot on January 20th, 2004 08:46 am (UTC)
*flings arms around Vikki's neck*

Thank you, that never occurred to me and now I feel like a complete idiot. Where *have* my close-reading skills gotten off to?

That makes the timeline ever so much more reasonable. Probably only one promotion out of zone, then.

*wanders off in search of brain, whistling cheerfully*