Log in

No account? Create an account
09 April 2005 @ 07:53 am
Some Chapter 46 scans!  
Found them on ranobe.

Image hosted by ImageHost.org

Image hosted by ImageHost.org

Image hosted by ImageHost.org

Don't know if I should friend this entry though..
Tryxtryxkittie on April 9th, 2005 01:45 pm (UTC)
Hmm...I'm not saying that Winry won't try to shoot Scar if he comes at her, but...

Look at it this way. I don't know how strong manga!Scar is but, in the anime how many times has he gone up against soldiers? Hawkeye's soldiers, MANY of Hawkeye's soldiers shot at Scar, he dodged all the bullets. He's been up against alchemists like Basque Gran, even Armstrong tried to get him with his projectiles, Scar still got the upper hand.

And you're telling me that some little girl with a hand gun is gonna take him down? You're right, if Winry's bullet hits Scar, he's dead.

That is if Winry's bullet hits Scar. Even if she tries to kill Scar when he's running towards her, I don't think Scar's silly enough to just run straight into her bullet. Again, I hold firm to my belief. Scar vs. Winry = dead Winry. Sorry, not that I don't like Winry, but I'm not going to believe the implausible just to support her.
chrononuriko on April 9th, 2005 02:22 pm (UTC)
Scar's weaker in the manga.

I mean, he's a pretty good fighter still, and he's dodged his fair amount of stuff...but the manga has a tendency to be more realistic than the anime, and he's never done those crazy acrobatics as he dodges a million military bullets in the manga like he did in the anime.

If someone's pointing a gun at him, he's pretty screwed. Sure, he can try to rush her and take her out, but unless she honestly can't bring herself to fire even when he's rushing towards her, Scar's going to get a bullet in him. Might not be fatal, but yeah...

The anime is pretty unrealistic when it comes to fights/injuries. The manga is much more realistic (Though still takes liberties in fights and all, being a fantasy manga with some action)...

Still, especially when it comes to stand-off scenes like this, Arakawa doesn't tend to use 'He dodges all the attacks!' cop outs.
Tryxtryxkittie on April 9th, 2005 04:17 pm (UTC)
Good points, but sorry still not convinced. If all one had to do in order to kill Scar was to point a gun and shoot, he'd be long gone by now. Hell, Hawkeye with all her skill in that area would have done the job with ease a long time ago. But oh well. Let's see how it works out.
chrononuriko on April 9th, 2005 04:27 pm (UTC)
Technically Scar in the manga hasn't even had a gun fired at him as far as I can remember.

Hawkeye as going to shoot him in chapter 45, but Ed decided to be stupid and tell her and Roy to stay out of it cuz he wants to avenge Winry's parents himself...